Some homes are admired. The one-of-a-kind ones are remembered...
This Warwick gem is set on five pastoral acres along coveted Bellvale Lakes Road, “The One Eyed Horse Farm” is an elegant turn-of-the-century Warwick countryside estate offering the romance of a Victorian residence, the ease of modern luxury, and the rare functionality of a turnkey horse farm, all approximately one hour from New York City. Equally idyllic as a full-time residence or refined weekend retreat, this is the kind of property that invites you to slow down, spread out, and live beautifully.

The estate is anchored by a large, approximately 3,000-SF on-site barn, adding exceptional value, versatility, and lifestyle appeal. One side is thoughtfully designed for equestrian and livestock use, featuring stalls, a tack room, and additional farm functionality. The other side offers renovated recreational space ideal for a private office, gym, art studio, music studio, yoga space, remote work area, or creative retreat. This rare combination transforms the property into more than a beautiful home. It becomes a true countryside estate, gentleman’s farm, horse property, creative compound, and private escape.

The home itself is rich with presence, craftsmanship, and warmth. A covered front porch welcomes you into gracious interiors with soaring ceilings, wide hallways, handcrafted banisters, original double-wide plank flooring, period trim, decorative fireplace mantels, and designer wallpaper that gives each room a distinct sense of style. Every space feels intentional, elegant, refined, comfortable, and deeply livable.

The impressive kitchen is designed for gathering, creating, and entertaining, offering the perfect balance of beauty and function. Elegant formal rooms invite dinner parties, holiday celebrations, and quiet evenings surrounded by architectural detail rarely found today. The primary ensuite offers a peaceful private retreat, while the additional bedrooms feel graceful, serene, and perfectly positioned to wake to the beauty of Warwick’s changing seasons.

Outdoors, the setting is pure countryside magic. Rolling open acreage, dramatic skies, seasonal color, and wide rainbows after a summer rain create a backdrop that feels almost cinematic. Morning coffee on the porch, afternoons in the barn or studio, evenings under open skies, and weekends surrounded by nature make this property as much a lifestyle as it is a home.

Adding to its remarkable story, former Tonight Show with Johnny Carson bandleader Doc Severinsen once owned the property for many years and is said to have built the shed so he could practice his trumpet there. Music, creativity, history, and echoes of a glamorous era still feel woven into the spirit of this extraordinary Warwick estate.

A rare offering on Bellvale Lakes Road, where turn-of-the-century Victorian character, modern amenities, pastoral beauty, turnkey horse farm functionality, renovated recreational barn space, and iconic provenance come together in a countryside estate designed to be lived in, loved, and remembered.